The IRS Scandal: A Nixonian Approach?

Screen Shot 2013 05 22 at 8.03.19 AM The IRS Scandal: A Nixonian Approach? The Obama administration continues to do itself no favors in the controversy involving the Internal Revenue Service. The scandal has already prompted the resignation of Acting IRS Chief Steven Miller and spawned both Congressional hearings and a Justice Department criminal inquiry.

In this week’s installment, administration officials offered contradictory information about when they found out the IRS was targeting politically conservative groups for additional scrutiny. On Sunday, a White House representative told the Sunday talk shows the issue hit the presidential radar the previous week.  A day later, however, White House spokesman Jay Carney revealed that several senior aides, including President Obama’s chief of staff and a senior White House attorney, knew about the matter more than a month ago, but chose not to tell the president.  Certain senior U.S. Treasury officials knew about IRS activities last year. IRS official Lois Lerner shed no additional light in her testimony before Congress: she pleaded the Fifth Amendment, invoking her right against self-incrimination.

Fair or not, the progression of events has begun to draw comparisons to another political era: that of Richard “Tricky Dick” Nixon. Prior to the Watergate scandal that ultimately swamped his presidency, Nixon wielded the IRS as a bludgeon against those on his “enemies list”. It was also during the congressional inquiry into Watergate that Senator Howard Baker, a Tennessee Republican, posed the now famous political question: What did the President know, and when did he know it? When it comes to the current scandal, the answer to that question seems far from clear.

THE PR VERDICT:  “F” (Full Fiasco) for the Obama administration. At best, the administration looks confused and inept; at worst, bullying and devious.

THE PR TAKEAWAY:  The buck always stops at the top. A school of thought exists wherein keeping bad news from senior management is believed to provide protection from fallout. That’s the wrong approach. Whether president or CEO, an organization’s leader is always held accountable for its behavior. When things go awry, the best plan is to move quickly to apprise leadership, sort out the facts, take remedial action if necessary and be prepared to speak knowledgeably about the matter if needed. Anything less is asking for trouble.

Who Knew Tricky Dick Was Such A Romantic?

ricahrd nixon 242x300 Who Knew Tricky Dick Was Such A Romantic?

The PR Verdict: “B” Smart move from the guardians of Nixon’s reputation.

What’s the best way to reform a reputation?….Surprise people.

The Richard Nixon Presidential Library has just released six of the former President’s love letters to the woman that would become his wife, Pat.  In the case of Richard Nixon the strategy of reforming a reputation by stealth seems to be working.

Nicknamed “tricky Dick” by his detractors (and there were many), Nixon’s tarnished career ended when he resigned the presidency. The rehabilation of his image has followed a familiar strategy. Let the ugly defining moment pass and introduce ongoing new material to provide a different perspective.

The letters make surprising reading. As the curator enthused to the media, “It’s a totally different person from the Watergate tapes that people know…. There’s a lot of hope, there’s a lot of tenderness and it’s very poetic”.

The PR Verdict: “B” Smart move from the guardians of Nixon’s reputation.  Only six letters, but they put the former President in a different light.

“Let’s go for a long ride Sunday; let’s go to the mountains weekends; let’s read books in front of fires; most of all, let’s really grow together and find the happiness we know is ours” he wrote to Pat. These breathless romantic scribblings will surprise many. Remembered more for his sweating in front of TV cameras than tender words, these short letters will move the perception toward a deeper and more nuanced character…..Now, does anyone have love letters from recently deceased Kim Jon Il to hand?

To read more about the letters click here and to take the Vanity Fair quiz on the letters click here.  Is there a news item that you think needs a grade? Send us your suggestion for the next PR Verdict: info@prverdict.com

What’s your PR verdict on these letters? Will they help reform Tricky Dick’s image?

[polldaddy poll=5996901]